brookfieldnow.com
search all things local
Rummage MapseHarmony
weather

47°

Partly Cloudy | 6MPH

NEWSROOM * CIRCULATION * ADVERTISING

Friday

November 2009

20

Blog Home |  Email Author  |        Welcome to MilwaukeeMoms Sign in | Join

Driving Miss Cranky

Name: Karen Waldkirch
Kids: Son, age 20; daughter, age 16
Works: Freelance writer, stay-at-home mom
Favorite part of being a mom: Building strong bodies 12 ways.
Least favorite part of being a mom: Being immensely disliked quite often.
Famous for: Embarrassing my children whenever possible. (And watching far too much television in the 70s.)

The Twilight Moms

By Karen Waldkirch
Monday, Oct 6 2008, 09:25 AM

I had no plans to read it. I often walked past it at Barnes & Noble and made bold and incorrect assumptions about its fan base. But then this article piqued my interest and I couldn’t resist.

 

What am I talking about? Stephanie Meyer’s vampire saga Twilight of course. This four-book young adult phenomenon has critics making comparisons to the power of Potter…Harry Potter, that is. (I’m here to tell you that J.K. Rowling has nothing to worry about.)

 

What intrigued (and scared me a little) was that Twilight has attracted a large audience of middle-aged women. What does that mean? Who likes reading about vampires? Busty matrons that work at Renaissance Faire all summer speaking in faux British accents? That definitely isn’t the crowd that I hang around! (Not that there's anything wrong with busty matrons!)

 

Still, I bit (pardon the pun) and picked up a copy. I’m a sucker for, at the very least, understanding a pop culture blockbuster. It took a few pages, but very quickly I figured it out. Twilight is escapist literature in every way. It’s mind candy for those of us who like to read, but sometimes need a break from thinking. It’s filled with drama and romance and teen angst.

 

And then there are the characters. Bella, a beautiful, yet supposedly klutzy young woman who kinda hates the world and everyone in it. Edward, a drop-dead gorgeous high school guy who happens to be a vampire. It won’t ruin the plot to tell you that they fall in love. There are, of course, complications, which is what makes it fun.

 

I have had some of the most animated book discussions ever about the Twilight series. Once you find a Twilight mom, it’s hard to calm them down. They gush and rave and reluctantly admit to ignoring laundry, dinner and children just to finish another chapter. I haven’t seen people this excited about a bestseller since The DaVinci Code!

 

Is Twilight great fiction? No, but that’s OK. Not everything is or should be. I’m a firm believer in supporting anything that gets people opening up a book and escaping into another world.

 

Oh, and for me, here’s the best part about it: Twilight is the first book that my teenage daughter and I both read and enjoyed. Usually, in literature (and in fashion), my stamp of approval is the kiss of death. Twilight was the rare thing we could agree upon. Bonus!

 

Come November 21st, there’s a good chance that you’ll find me and a friend or two in line to see the Twilight motion picture. Why won’t I be going with my daughter? What, are you kidding?! Now that’s fiction!

 

What about you? Are you a Twilight mom? Are you on “Team Edward” or “Team Jacob”? (You have to read Twilight to understand what that means.) Comment below or e-mail me at misscrankyblog@yahoo.com .

 

 

Filed under:
Permalink |  Mail to a friend

Comments

molly0617   

I too love this series.  I have always loved all things vampire -- and I agree it is because of it's "escapist" feel.  

Oh, and I am very much on team Edward.  Although I do love Jacob.  

October 6, 2008 9:38 AM

Meg McKenna   

Hi, Karen,

Even if my kids are handling Harry Potter, would you think this book series is too old for them, given the romance angle?  What do you think would be the minimum age end this series is appropriate for?

October 6, 2008 12:39 PM

Karen Waldkirch   

Meg, good question. Personally, I think this is for kids who are 14 or older. I know of some parents that have let middle school kids read it, but I just think the subject matter is too mature for them. Although the romance in Twilight is rather "chaste," it still carries innuendo. Harry Potter is completely different than Twilight.

October 6, 2008 3:05 PM

Heather Dorsey   

I believe I am one of the moms who had an "animated" conversation with you about this series.  I've really enjoyed the first three books and do have some trouble putting them down.  Like you said, they are just good escapism "chick lit."

My only problem is some of the bizarre dreams I've had from reading these novels right before bedtime.  I'm sure the movie will be even worse for that, but I can't wait to see it!

October 13, 2008 10:07 PM

Scott Lone   

Twilight is all the rage among high school girls these days.  I find at least one copy in each of my classes and I don't teach literature.  In fact, I've had to confiscate a few copies since the year started because the book becomes the lesson.  The books are returned to their owners at the end of class - just wish I could teach in the manner that this book captivates!  Glad our teens are finding something worthwhile to read that does not distort their minds into programmed, rote thinking.

October 14, 2008 8:25 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.

About Karen Waldkirch

Karen is a freelance writer who moonlights as a stay-at-home mom of two children (ages 16 and 20). She freely admits to being a tennis and pop culture addict. During the fall and winter, if she is not on the indoor courts, you will find her in the stands at Green Bay Packer and Marquette basketball games.
 
The opinions and views expressed by Community Voice writers do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Journal Interactive, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel or Community Newspapers. MyCommunityNow.com does not control, is not responsible for, and does not guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of, the postings on this Web log. Readers can report objectionable content by clicking here.